Shoulda Said

There are various ways to play this game. Some players call “Shoulda said” almost randomly. (Audiences often do the same.) A better approach is to use it on lines that could be improved, usually because they are indecisive or emotionally neutral.

PAUL: So, how was the interview?

AMY: Fine, fine. They said they’ll let me know by next Thursday.

CALLER: Shoulda said!

AMY: I GOT THE JOB!!!

Paul and Amy high-five.

A caller will often need to take a couple of goes to push the player into a different frame of mind.
Players should take the “shoulda said” as an opportunity to make a stronger emotional choice. Very verbal players will instead give quick, panicky responses, offering minor variations on a dull statement.

PAUL: How was your afternoon?

BEN: Meh. My sister’s dog ran away.

CALLER: Shoulda said!

BEN: Meh. My sister’s cat ran away.

CALLER: Shoulda said!

BEN: Meh. My sister’s hamster ran away.

A better choice would have changed the reaction rather than just changing the words. This would automatically lead to a stronger choice.

BEN: Terrible! My sister ran away!

A Non-Variation

If your ego is too delicate to deal with the criticism implied with by the words “shoulda said,” you can instead call “Different Choice.” The resulting game is identical.